Your PEEK Into The Day: 5 Stories That Deserve The Front Page
Peek TV | September 24, 2026
India’s Poll Wall Cracks: Indian Express Lays Bare The Watchdog’s ‘Free & Fair Facade’
The Fact: An Indian Express investigation has revealed an unprecedented internal rift within the Election Commission of India. In the last 10 months, two of the three Election Commissioners recorded objections 14 times to various aspects of the Special Intensive Revision exercise and decisions made without their knowledge. The objections touch the core of the Election Commission’s mandate: registration of new voters, deletion and restoration of names from electoral rolls, even the security of the entire electoral database.
The Context: Key flashpoints included unauthorized Form 6 voter registration changes, centralizing IT database access that bypassed statutory EROs, and unvetted appeals filed in West Bengal. To challenge these moves, the dissenting Commissioners issued formal file notes invoking the 2023 Act and the Constitution, reversed contentious work allocation orders, and even knocked on the Cabinet Secretary’s door over software integrity. Responding to the report, the Commission defended the notes as normal "decision-making" and "suggestions", maintaining that all major actions were unanimous. The Election Commission comprises three equal members, Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar and Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, with the CEC acting as first among equals. The core mandate of the ECI, anchored under Article 324 of the Constitution, is to ensure free, fair, and transparent democratic processes across the nation. A critical element of this is managing the vital cycle of voter registration and deletion. This includes updating and maintaining nationwide electoral rolls, processing new voter applications, and overseeing initiatives like the Special Intensive Revision.
The Peek Insight: For years now, the Opposition has levelled grave allegations against the Election Commission and the BJP, with Rahul Gandhi claiming that they "colluded to steal" the 2024 Lok Sabha elections. However, the Express investigation raises a crucial question: what happens when doubts about the ECI’s functioning are raised from within the body itself? The main issue is that the ECI can not just claim to be independent, it must also be seen to act independently and inspire public confidence. With so many opposition leaders repeating the rhetoric of a ‘compromised’ ECI, so many genuine voters and larger democracy at stake, there must be a thorough investigation into the proceedings of the ECI.
